Wisconsin Cheese

America’s Dairyland, Crafted by Master Cheesemakers

Explore a curated selection of Wisconsin cheeses, from classic cheddars and Colby to alpine-style, blue, and specialty styles. Made by artisan producers, these cheeses reflect the quality and tradition behind America’s Dairyland.

43 Products
43 Products
Lake Effect

Blakesville Creamery

Lake Effect Cheese

American Cheese

New School

American Cheese

afterglow cheese

Blakesville Creamery

Afterglow Cheese

St. Germain

Blakesville Creamery

St. Germain Cheese

What Makes Wisconsin Cheese Special

Wisconsin is recognized worldwide as the center of American cheesemaking, with a heritage rooted in Old World traditions and elevated by modern artisan craftsmanship. The state’s cool climate, rich pastureland, and dedication to dairy excellence produce exceptional milk, which is the foundation of truly great cheese. What sets Wisconsin apart is its unparalleled concentration of licensed cheesemakers, many of whom have trained for decades to master aging, flavor development, and traditional production methods.

At iGourmet, our Wisconsin Cheese collection goes far beyond everyday grocery store offerings. We focus on artisan and small-batch cheeses crafted by producers who prioritize quality over volume. Every cheese is carefully tasted and evaluated by our team for flavor, balance, texture, and authenticity before it is selected. This thoughtful curation ensures that each cheese in this collection represents the very best of Wisconsin’s cheesemaking tradition.

Enjoying and Pairing Wisconsin Cheese

Wisconsin cheeses are exceptionally versatile and well-suited for cheese boards, entertaining, and elevated everyday meals. Aged cheddars and alpine-style cheeses pair beautifully with artisan crackers and crusty breads (artisan crackers and crusty breads), while creamy blues and softer cheeses are excellent alongside honey, fig spreads, or fruit preserves (honey, fig spreads, or fruit preserves). These accompaniments enhance the cheese without overshadowing its natural character.

For a complete tasting experience, consider adding charcuterie such as cured meats or pâtés (charcuterie), which provide savory contrast and texture. When selecting beverages, bold and aged Wisconsin cheeses pair well with red wines, hard ciders, or craft beers, while milder styles shine with white or sparkling wines (wine).

Cooking, Entertaining, and Gifting

Many Wisconsin cheeses are prized for their excellent melting qualities, making them ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches, macaroni and cheese, burgers, fondue, and baked dishes. Others are best enjoyed simply sliced or crumbled, allowing their craftsmanship and aging to take center stage. This versatility makes Wisconsin cheese a natural choice for both casual meals and special occasions.

Wisconsin cheese is also an excellent option for gifting, particularly when paired with curated assortments from our cheese gift boxes (cheese gift boxes), which are designed for sharing and discovering new favorites.

Explore Similar Cheese Styles and Related Collections

If you enjoy Wisconsin cheese and would like to explore similar styles or expand your selection, these collections offer natural next steps:

These related categories help you compare styles, refine your preferences, and build a more diverse cheese selection.

Why Buy Wisconsin Cheese from iGourmet

iGourmet offers an epicurean selection of cheeses sourced from respected producers who share our commitment to craftsmanship and quality. Every Wisconsin cheese we sell is carefully selected, properly stored, and shipped with care to preserve freshness and flavor. When you order from iGourmet, you’re gaining access to a thoughtfully curated collection chosen by experts passionate about exceptional food.

Wisconsin Cheese: Frequently Asked Questions

Wisconsin cheese is made using high-quality milk from local dairy farms and crafted by licensed cheesemakers who must meet strict production and quality standards. This results in cheeses that are consistently well-balanced, properly aged, and full of character.

Yes. Many Wisconsin cheeses are produced in small batches using traditional techniques such as long aging, clothbinding, and natural rind development, emphasizing flavor and craftsmanship over mass production.

iGourmet sources directly from trusted producers and stores cheese under optimal conditions before shipping. Each order is carefully packed so cheese arrives fresh and ready to enjoy.

The best way to store cut cheese is in breathable cheese storage bags, which help regulate moisture and protect flavor while allowing the cheese to breathe (cheese storage bags). Cheese storage bags are ideal for maintaining freshness and extending the life of artisan cheese in your refrigerator.

Absolutely. Wisconsin cheeses are well known for their excellent melting properties in cooked dishes, while aged and specialty cheeses are ideal for cheese boards, entertaining, and gifting.