Extremely Scary Cheese Collection

It's like playing Fear Factor with your food! This international collection of handcrafted, holiday-inspired cheeses is geared towards adventurous eaters. From unapologetically stinky to pretty darn sharp to an otherworldly cheese that literally breathes fire (thanks to spicy add-ins like habaneros and paprika), it's the perfect assortment for Halloween celebrants whose tastes run well beyond basic cheddar.

• Natural Wafer Crackers by Rutherford and Meyer: Looking for the perfect base to build your Halloween horrors? These Natural Wafer Crackers are scarily good at showcasing all the bold and wild flavors in this box. Light and crispy, they won’t overshadow your more daring cheeses but will give you just enough crunch to make every bite a "graveyard smash." Great for stacking with spooky spreads and cheeses that pack a punch!
• The Rattlesnake by Deer Creek: It's a cheese that bites back! This award-winning Wisconsin company starts with The Dairy State's best-known specialty, cheddar. But true to its name, the Rattlesnake bares its teeth due to the addition of smoldering habanero peppers. Way up there on the Scoville scale, the fruity chilies give the otherwise smooth and tangy cheese a distinctively fiery quality.
• Dream Weaver by Central Coast Creamery: This cheese is the stuff of sweet dreams—or nightmares, depending on your taste! Dream Weaver by Central Coast Creamery brings a rich, buttery texture with an unexpectedly sharp twist. Creamy yet tangy, this cheese will lull you in with its smoothness, then surprise you with its bright, lively flavor. Pair it with some crackers, and watch your guests become “cheese zombies,” coming back for more!
• Botanero Cheese with Cilantro and Jalapeno by Don Froylan: Beware, this cheese has a devilish bite! Botanero Cheese is a spicy, herb-infused creation that’s anything but basic. Infused with jalapeños and fresh cilantro, it’s a cheese that’s fresh and fiery at the same time. Perfect for adding a little heat to your Halloween party, this cheese will cast a spell over anyone who loves bold, herbal flavors. Serve it with some chilled beer to tame the burn—or add to the fun!
• Wooly Wooly Everything Seasoning Cheese by Mitica: This cheese is baa-aaaad to the bone! Wooly Wooly brings together the savory flavors of everything bagel seasoning with the creamy, tangy goodness of sheep's milk cheese. It’s a monstrously good combo that will keep your taste buds howling with delight. Perfect for spreading on crackers or pairing with fresh veggies, it’s a snack that’s a little wild and a lot of fun—just like your Halloween bash!

Please note that any item temporarily out of stock will be substituted with a similar item of equal value.