Buttery pumpkin, sweet brown sugar, apple cider and spices combine for a taste as close to real pumpkin pie as you can get! Prissy's Pumpkin Butter is prepared using a time-honored Southern technique. The creamiest of the creamiest! This historic recipe is simmered long and slow until it is just the right sweetness. This is a great spread on toast, muffins, and biscuits, and it also complements a turkey sandwich! Fat free. Two-year shelf life.